I uploaded Risuko to http://usabookreviewers.com/ through IBPA last December, six months before the book’s mid-June release. Since then; I’ve gotten over 250 responses, with a few more still dribbling in. Most of the have been from reviewers (largely bloggers and Goodreads habitués, but a few from commercial media), but nearly ten percent have been from librarians and about five percent from booksellers, whom I’m continuing to follow up with.
As each person posts a response, http://usabookreviewers.com/ generates an email including:
Their email address and name
Their overall rating (on a five-star scale)
Any feedback or review they might have
Whether or not they like the cover
Whether or not they like the description
Whether they want to hear from the author or publisher
If they’re a reviewer:
Whether they’d buy the book for friend (if they’re a reviewer)
Where (if anywhere) they’ve published/posted their review
If they’re a librarian:
Whether they’ll be ordering the book for their library
Whether they’d recommend the book to:
their patrons
book clubs
a number of library reading lists
If they’re a bookseller:
Whether they’ll be carrying the book in their store
Whether they’ll be hand-selling/recommending the book to their patrons
Obviously that’s a lot of useful data.
Some folks just leave a rating, but most leave a few sentences to hundreds of words of feedback — positive or negative, it’s (nearly always) helpful. Often they share the URL of their online review, which you can link to in your own social media or quote from on your website. If they say they want to hear from you, you can follow up with them, but you can also add them to your mailing list (though it’s important to ask first).
And of course, I contacted all of the five-star reviewers and asked them to post on Amazon. 🙂
The reviews were generally positive, which is nice — though, obviously, not all were. As an example of how the feedback can serve as helpful marketing research, the most consistent knock I got was that my description made the book sound (even) more action-packed than it was. I used that feedback to tweak the blurb, and am using the original “Can one girl win a war?” tag for the series — which it fits better. A number of people also commented that the book felt more like a middle-grade book (aimed at 10- to 13-year-olds) than a young-adult one (aimed at 13- to 18-year-olds) — I listed Risuko in both categories. That was good to know from a marketing point of view, though the later books are going to get more adult.
As each person posts a response, http://usabookreviewers.com/ generates an email including:
Their email address and name
Their overall rating (on a five-star scale)
Any feedback or review they might have
Whether or not they like the cover
Whether or not they like the description
Whether they want to hear from the author or publisher
If they’re a reviewer:
Whether they’d buy the book for friend (if they’re a reviewer)
Where (if anywhere) they’ve published/posted their review
If they’re a librarian:
Whether they’ll be ordering the book for their library
Whether they’d recommend the book to:
their patrons
book clubs
a number of library reading lists
If they’re a bookseller:
Whether they’ll be carrying the book in their store
Whether they’ll be hand-selling/recommending the book to their patrons
Obviously that’s a lot of useful data.
Some folks just leave a rating, but most leave a few sentences to hundreds of words of feedback — positive or negative, it’s (nearly always) helpful. Often they share the URL of their online review, which you can link to in your own social media or quote from on your website. If they say they want to hear from you, you can follow up with them, but you can also add them to your mailing list (though it’s important to ask first).
And of course, I contacted all of the five-star reviewers and asked them to post on Amazon. 🙂
The reviews were generally positive, which is nice — though, obviously, not all were. As an example of how the feedback can serve as helpful marketing research, the most consistent knock I got was that my description made the book sound (even) more action-packed than it was. I used that feedback to tweak the blurb, and am using the original “Can one girl win a war?” tag for the series — which it fits better. A number of people also commented that the book felt more like a middle-grade book (aimed at 10- to 13-year-olds) than a young-adult one (aimed at 13- to 18-year-olds) — I listed Risuko in both categories. That was good to know from a marketing point of view, though the later books are going to get more adult.